Felicia “Lisa” Weaver Disappears Without a Trace After House Fire in Hayden Alabama

On the afternoon of February 5, 2015, Felicia Ann “Lisa” Weaver, a 52‑year‑old resident of Hayden in Blount County, Alabama, vanished under baffling circumstances when her home on Jack Cole Road erupted in flames. At approximately 2:37 p.m., Lisa exchanged a final text message—“I love you too”—with her son Michael Mullins. Twenty‑three minutes later, Michael learned the house was “engulfed in flames,” yet no trace of Lisa was ever found amid the wreckage. Fire crews recovered only the charred remains of the family’s three dogs and found no human remains, footprints, or sign that Lisa had escaped on her own .

Early Life and Family Background

Born Felicia Ann Weaver, Lisa spent most of her life in Blount County, where she maintained close ties with her extended family. She had three sons from a previous marriage and was known among relatives as a devoted mother who loved crafting and gardening. In her later years, Lisa’s health declined dramatically, and she became increasingly dependent on her family’s support. Although she endured numerous hospitalizations for respiratory issues, her unwavering spirit and sense of humor endeared her to neighbors and friends in the tight‑knit Hayden community .

Health Decline and Living Situation

By late 2014, Lisa had reached end‑stage chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and was prescribed continuous, bottled oxygen to breathe. Walking beyond a few dozen yards left her breathless, and medical professionals had begun to discuss hospice care with her family. To ensure round‑the‑clock supervision, Lisa moved into her ex‑husband’s home on Jack Cole Road, along with two of her adult sons. There, they adapted the living space for her medical equipment and attempted to maintain as normal a life as possible, given her severe limitations .

The Day of the Fire

On the morning of February 5, Michael Mullins left the house around midday to visit friends, leaving Lisa alone but connected via her iPad. Their last digital exchange occurred at 2:37 p.m., after which all communication ceased. At approximately 3 p.m., Michael received an urgent call: his mother’s home was ablaze. Arriving on scene, he watched firefighters battle the intense inferno. No accelerant was detected, and emergency personnel reported the fire had spread rapidly, likely fed by household materials and oxygen tank contents—but standard protocol prevented them from entering until the blaze was under control .

Fire Investigation Findings

The Alabama State Fire Marshal’s Office, collaborating with the Blount County Sheriff’s Department, examined the charred remains after the flames were extinguished. Investigators found no obvious signs of foul play—no suspicious fuel sources, forced entry points, or tampered gas lines. Despite the absence of accelerants, the blaze’s ferocity obliterated much of the home’s interior, leaving behind twisted metal, ash, and debris. Lisa’s car remained parked in the driveway, her purse and oxygen tank inside, suggesting she never departed before the fire. Yet, curiously, no remains or personal items of hers were located within or around the property .

Search Efforts and Community Involvement

In the weeks following the fire, searches extended beyond the smoldering ruins. Cadaver dogs scoured the debris pile, while helicopter crews swept the neighboring woodlands for any sign of Lisa’s body. Volunteers—including family, friends, and community members—organized ground searches through dense underbrush, hoping to find evidence of her passing. A Facebook page, “Help Bring Lisa Weaver Home,” was launched to coordinate efforts and share updates. Despite these exhaustive searches, no trace of Lisa emerged, deepening the mystery surrounding her fate .

Leading Theories and Speculation

Multiple theories have circulated among investigators and armchair sleuths alike:

• Homicide Concealment: Some believe Lisa may have been killed inside the home, with the fire set deliberately to destroy evidence.
• Pre‑Fire Abduction: Others suggest she was forcibly removed just before the fire, her vulnerability exploited by an unknown perpetrator.
• Accidental Death in Blaze: Given the oxygen tank fueling the fire, it’s possible Lisa perished in the blaze and her remains were consumed beyond recognition.
• Disoriented Escape: In a more tragic scenario, Lisa may have fled into the woods without her oxygen, succumbing to hypoxia or exposure—her remains blending into the forest floor.

Blog posts and Reddit threads detail alternative ideas—ranging from an accidental oxygen tank explosion to assisted suicide and even spontaneous human combustion—but none have been substantiated by evidence. Official statements maintain that foul play cannot be confirmed or ruled out conclusively .

Media Coverage and Public Response

National true‑crime blogs and local news outlets have spotlighted Lisa’s case, drawing attention to the peculiar circumstances of her disappearance. CrimeSolversCentral and NamUs list her as an endangered missing person, though publicly viewable details on NamUs remain sparse. Each anniversary of the fire renews media interest, with reporters revisiting the unsolved mystery. Community vigils and anniversary searches are held on the property, where floral tributes and handwritten notes testify to enduring hope—and heartbreak—among those who knew her .

Ongoing Investigation and Appeal for Information

As of 2025, the Blount County Sheriff’s Office continues to treat Lisa’s disappearance as an active, suspicious case. Investigators have periodically reviewed technological advances—such as improved DNA analysis techniques—to reexamine existing evidence. No new leads have emerged publicly, and Lisa’s whereabouts remain unknown. Authorities urge anyone with information, however small, to come forward. The case file number is MP27872 in NamUs, and tips can be submitted to the Blount County Sheriff’s Office at (205) 625‑4127 .

Conclusion

More than a decade after that fateful February afternoon, the disappearance of Felicia Ann “Lisa” Weaver continues to baffle law enforcement and haunt her family. A woman once known for her warm smile and tenacity in the face of illness has become a symbol of unresolved loss. Whether her fate lies in the ashes of her own home, the shadowy stretches of the surrounding woods, or the sinister intentions of another, only time—or a new eyewitness—may bring closure to this tragic mystery.